Last Updated: May 2026

    Audit vs. Review vs. Compilation

    A plain-English guide to the three levels of CPA financial statement services — what each means, when it's required, and what it costs in DC, Maryland, and Virginia.

    What is the difference between a compilation, review, and audit?

    A compilation has no CPA assurance — the accountant presents financial statements without verifying them. A review provides limited assurance through analytical procedures and management inquiries. A full audit provides the highest assurance level, with independent testing, confirmations, and a formal opinion. Cost ranges from $1,500 for a compilation to $40,000+ for a complex audit.

    Key Definitions

    Compilation
    A compilation is a CPA engagement under SSARS where the accountant presents financial statements based on management-provided information without expressing assurance or verifying the data.
    Review
    A review is a CPA engagement providing limited assurance that nothing came to the accountant's attention indicating the financial statements are not fairly presented, based on analytical procedures and inquiries.
    Audit
    An audit is an independent examination of financial statements providing reasonable (not absolute) assurance that statements are fairly presented in accordance with GAAP, following Generally Accepted Auditing Standards.

    Audit vs. Review vs. Compilation: Side-by-Side Comparison

    FeatureCompilationReviewAudit
    CPA assurance levelNone (no opinion)Limited assuranceReasonable assurance
    Independence requiredYesYesYes
    Testing of transactions
    Analytical procedures
    Management inquiries
    Confirmation of balances
    CPA opinion issued
    Typical cost (DC/MD/VA)$1,500–$5,000$4,000–$10,000$8,000–$40,000+
    Timeline1–3 weeks3–6 weeks6–12 weeks
    GAGAS (Yellow Book) option

    Choosing the Right Level of Service

    When a Compilation Is the Right Choice

    Compilations are appropriate when management needs financial statements presented in a standard format but no outside party requires independent assurance. Common use cases include:

    • Real estate disclosure requirements (e.g., condo association budgets)
    • Franchise agreements requiring financial statements from franchisees
    • Internal management reporting that needs to be CPA-formatted
    • Smaller nonprofits below state charitable solicitation audit thresholds

    When a Review Makes Sense

    Reviews provide a meaningful level of independent assurance at a fraction of audit cost. Consider a review when:

    • Applying for bank loans of $250,000–$1,000,000 (many lenders accept reviews)
    • Your HOA bylaws require independent financial assurance but not a full audit
    • Your nonprofit is below state audit thresholds but above compilation-acceptable levels
    • Investors or partners want independent assurance without full audit expense

    When a Full Audit Is Required

    Audits are required in specific regulatory and contractual situations:

    • SBA loans over $2M (required per SBA SOP 50 10 7)
    • Federal grants exceeding $1,000,000 (raised from $750,000 effective for fiscal years beginning on or after October 1, 2024) trigger Single Audit requirements (Uniform Guidance)
    • M&A due diligence — buyers require audited financials for target companies
    • Publicly regulated entities (PCAOB standards apply for SEC registrants)
    • Government contractors meeting DCAA audit thresholds
    • Employee benefit plans with 100+ participants (DOL requirement)

    Which Do DC/MD/VA Organizations Typically Need?

    Washington, DC

    • Nonprofits >$500K contributions: Audit required
    • Nonprofits $200K–$500K: Review acceptable
    • HOAs: Varies by bylaws
    • DC government contractors: GAGAS audit often required

    Maryland

    • Nonprofits >$750K: Audit required
    • Nonprofits $300K–$750K: Review acceptable
    • HOAs: Audit if 150+ units, else bylaws govern
    • MD state grants: Audit required for awards >$200K

    Virginia

    • Nonprofits >$1M: Audit required
    • Nonprofits $500K–$1M: Review acceptable
    • HOAs: Virginia Code §55.1-1954 governs
    • VA state contracts: Audit thresholds apply

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Related Services

    Not Sure Which Service You Need?

    Our licensed CPAs will review your situation and recommend the right level of service — compilation, review, or audit — based on your lender, grantor, or regulatory requirements.